Baby PencilBaby Pencil was in episode 17. She was recommend by simondomino. She is a baby version of Pencil wearing a diaper. She was seen sitting next to Baby Leafy and Baby Firey.
Black Pencil is a black-colored version of Pencil. She has white eyes and mouth to counter her body's colors. She appeared in Hurtful!, and was recommended by TDMShadowCP.
Blue PencilBlue Pencil was in episode 18. She is a blue-colored version of Pencil. She was recommended by Ipsgirl32.
Broken Pencil is literally Pencil broken in half. She was recommended by Carraid17. She appeared in Rescission as one of the recommended characters that got disintegrated when Pencil pressed the Emergency Button at them.
Carpenter's Pencil is a recommended character appeared in Get in the Van. He/She placed 2nd out of the Top 25 recommended characters in that episode, only exceeded by Waffle. He/She was recommended by wbnk.