Basically I judge who the best and worse images are by character.
[]
Personally I think Pencil has the best image, the color shading is the best out of the characters and I like her expression, sadly we'll never get to see it used properly.
The least good would have to be Fanny or Flower. Fanny cause I don't think the purple-red coloring matches with her blue color and Flower cause I'm not fond of the expression on her face.
[]
Rocky and Nickel second. Rockys the best pic cause I like the close up, sideways angle his bodies in. And then Nickel cause i like his running pose. Leafy would be third.
The least good would probably be Cloudy, the face is kinda weird.
[]
Now even though I absolutely hate Firey Jr right now, he has the best picture. He's very small so it's cool how it looks like he's walking against the edges of his image. Bracelety would be 2nd and Donut 3rd.
Bomby is the only character who's image I don't like cause it's so boring, just like Bomby himself.
[]
Like anyone else's image could beat Pen's. It really just goes along with how awesome he's been in this season. Next would be Bottle and Black Hole. Bottles is just hilarious. Saying Black Hole is weird but the fact that he's faceless and mysterious makes seeing his picture that much cooler.
The worst is easily Pies. Omg that smug face she's making makes me want to punch her until she explodes. And what is even going on with her limbs. The fact that we had to see this smug-ass face after an episode where she was absent and useless made it that much easier to vote her out for me.
[]
To be honest, there all good. Nobody has an image that stands out as the best and no one has an image that stands out as the worst. Every image matches its characters personality well.
[]
TV, 8-Ball, Grassy, and Blocky all have fantastic pictures but if I had to choose the best out of them, it's Blocky. The expression is priceless and a nice callback to his Funny Doings.
The least good is Golf Ball. Nothing against GB, but she looks a little to happy in her picture, considering how she acts I'd expect a stern expression or her face from the BFDIA intro.
[]
I LOVE Erasers picture, he looks so freaking cool and chill. And I love the teeth asset from Paper Towels.
The worst is easily Bell. I get that her being blurry in her picture might indicate how fast she can swing or something or it might just be a joke but it's a f*cking awful one at that, like what he heck is even the point. Just a terrible picture.
[]
I'm just gonna give my opinion on Book and Ice Cube's pics since we've seen them before.
Book's image looks really good. It matches her personality of being more sane then other characters sometimes and choice of color and shading looks nice. Ice Cubes picture pretty much nails hers character in the coffin, dull. I'd go as far as to say it screams "I am the boringest character on the team". Yet in some strange way I really like it for how simple it is. I'd currently rank them as
1st Ice Cube
2nd Book