Total Firey Island is an early version of Battle for Dream Island, which included all of the original BFDI contestants except Leafy, Needle, Pen, and Pin. David is also not included, as he was not introduced until Vomitaco since he was neither made by Cary nor Michael Huang. Therefore, TFI has 16 characters and 2 teams.
Only 9 books of the 18 were shown online on the Carykh YouTube channel. Books 1-9 were shown, though books 10-18 remain unseen to the public.
- Episode 1: Crying Contest (later used as a basis for the first contest in Crybaby!)
- Episode 2: Balance Beam (recycled for Take the Plunge: Part 1)
- Episode 3: Mile Run (course was used in Rescission's unicycle race)
- Episode 4: Elimination Volleyball!
- Episode 5: Rope Climb (Blocky's cheating leading to disqualification reused in Are You Smarter Than a Snowball?)
- Episode 6: Dodgeball
- Episode 7: Spelling Bee
- Episode 8: Breath Holding Contest (recycled as a gag at the end of It's a Monster)
- Episode 9: Dice! (Part of the judging in Sweet Tooth)
- (Books 10-18 are currently unreleased)
|1||2||3||4||5||6||7||8||9||10 ~ 18|
|N/A||Ice Cube||Yelling Beavers||WIN||WIN||IN||WIN||IN||IN||WIN||WIN||IN|
|8||Tennis Ball||Yelling Beavers||WIN||WIN||IN||WIN||IN||IN||WIN||WIN||OUT|
|15||Golf Ball||Murderer Trout||IN||OUT|
- The contestants not present at the time of its writing are Leafy, Needle, Pen, and Pin.
- David was also absent since he was a recommended character and joined late.
- The name is a reference to the Canadian TV series Total Drama Island.
- Cary Huang/Carykh confirmed that the rest of the books are in his old house. But unfortunately, he can't find them. It may be likely that the rest of the series may never be found.
- ↑ The boxes in pink mean that the contestant is female.
The boxes in blue mean that the contestant is male.