An asterisk means they are competing in season 2. X means they competed in season 2 but was eliminated.
|Name||Gender||Photo||Order voted off||Episode voted off||Number of votes at point of elimination|
|Power of Three||5|
|Half a Loaf Is Better Than None||66|
|Bowling, Now with Explosions!||144|
(returns in Insectophobe's Nightmare and switched to Squashy Grapes)
|Spongy *||Male||2nd||Are You Smarter Than a Snowball?|
(returns in Half a Loaf Is Better Than None)
|Bubble||Female||3rd place||Return of the Hang Glider||228 (To win)|
|Firey *||Male||Winner||Not eliminated|
(switched to Squashy Grapes, then to Another Name)
|406 (To win)|
- In Insectophobe's Nightmare, Snowball called the Squishy Cherries "Mushy Berries".
- This is the only team to not have all the members reappeared again in Battle for Dream Island Again.
- 4 of the 10 contestants have been on at least 2 teams.
- After Spongy got eliminated in episode 3, Squishy Cherries was the only team that has all members with arms until episode 11, when Rocky joined the team.