- Main article: Donut
- Main article: Sky
One Person Per Recommender SignOne Person Per Recommender Sign is a sign that appeared in Hurtful! and Insectophobe's Nightmare 2. It is a sign to remind people that there can only one recommended character per recommender. It was recommended by ShinyGenesectAron2.
Its appearances had a couple reminders that copyrighted characters were excluded from the crowd, not wanting them to be sued. Also, the stick was moved to the far right, and another face was made there, saying "I am off balance! Hooray for me!"
- In the BFDI Recommended Characters video, the version that appeared in Hurtful! was listed to appear in Reveal Novum.
Evil Flower Speaker
Purple Round Speaker
Dream Island is a recommended character from Insectophobe's Nightmare 2. It is really badly drawn, mini Dream Island. It is also one of the few that appear to be actually non-sentient. It was recommended by edtrin175.
Rocky with Glasses
Red and Blue Firey
Leafy Troll Face
SB (orange)"SB" (orange) is a character that was recommended by SBProductions12 in Insectophobe's Nightmare 2. It looks like an orange angry or unamused Yellow Face with limbs. SB likely means the initials SB in the recommender's name, though it may mean Snowball as he also goes by that initials.
Robot Ice Cube
Fire Pie (cherry)
Bubble Speaker Box
Previous BFDI Episodes
GrayGray is a recommended character from Insectophobe's Nightmare 2. It looks like a big puddle that is gray. It was recommended by DeeandEd.
- Gray is the second color recommended character, the first being Red.
Evil Ice Cube
Voted Out Contestants
Foamy The Squirrel
A poorly Drawn version of The Cartoon character with the same name
Match and Pencil as Enemies
Match and Pencil as Enemies are recommended characters in a duo. They are poorly drawn variations of Match and Pencil. They made their first, and so far only appearance in Insectophobe's Nightmare 2 getting eaten by the bugs with all the other recommended characters in Episode 24. They appear to stand away from each other with angry faces, showing that they are enemies. They were recommended by MrDoubleGAngster.
Freaked Out Bally
SB and GB as BFFsSB and GB as BFFs is a recommended character from Insectophobe's Nightmare 2. It is a badly-drawn Snowball and Golf Ball smiling at each other. It was recommended by MrTristan626.
- Strangely, Golf Ball’s eye(s) are missing.
- A version including Golf Ball's eyes can be seen seen in Carykh's BFDI Recommended Characters video.
- Main article: Grand Cake
Every Recommended Character
Crazy NeedleCrazy Needle was a recommended character that appeared in Insectophobe's Nightmare 2. It is a rainbow-colored variation of Needle which is sloppily drawn. In the episode, Crazy Needle was eaten by the bugs along with all of the other recommended characters. It was recommended by alexlion0511.
Square Coiny with Round Edges
Square Coiny with Rounded Edges is a recommended character that appeared in Insectophobe's Nightmare 2. It is a rounded rectangle that is copper-colored, and like its name suggests, meant to resemble Coiny (but is slightly darker). It was recommended by beanme100. It was one of the many recommended characters who got eaten by the bugs.
Flower Recovery Center
Lava TeardropLava Teardrop was a recommended character who appeared in Insectophobe's Nightmare 2. It was a badly drawn version of Teardrop that is made of lava, a form of molten rock out of the Earth's crust. It died later when it was eaten by the Announcer's bugs later that episode.
- Main article: Watermelon
Purple Girl with Wind Hair and Angry Eyes
Rocky Speaker Box
Rose the Flower
HeatcubeHeatcube is a recommended character from Insectophobe's Nightmare 2. It is a badly drawn, red, armless square (similar to Blocky) that is on fire. It was recommended by iCakeJake.
- Heatcube seems to be the opposite of Ice Cube.
Candy CornCandy Corn is a recommended character from Insectophobe's Nightmare 2.
Flower's Biggest Fan
Flower HaterFlower Hater is a recommended character that appeared in Insectophobe's Nightmare 2. They look like David with Flower's head on its body with a red cross on it, indicating its hatred for Flower. They were eaten by the Announcer's bugs later in the episode. They reappeared in Return of the Hang Glider with every other recommended character.
Strawberry with Green Dots
Troll Face Rocky
Giant, Pink, Evil Leafy
Another Namey (logo)
Hot Pink Tennis Ball
- Main article: Bracelety