Beginning
These characters were destroyed by Pencil because she was "tired of [them] too". (With the exception of Emergency Button who was used to disintegrate them)
- Emergency Button
- Laptoppy
- Lego
- Companion Cube
- Hot Dog
- Plate
- Laptop
- Laptop
- Laptop
- Sunglassy
- Glasses
- Tornado
- Crayon
- Typewriter
- Speaker Clone
- Sprite
- Pink Snowball
- Discy
- Mr. Penguin
- Penguin
- Chip
- Water Cup
- Cheez-It
- Dorito
- Block-of-Cheesy
- Blu-Ray Player
- Broken Pencil
- Tonguey - By ILVGwebmaster
- Celly
- Cell Phone
- Pina Colada
- Water Bottle
- Microphone
- Yellow Leafy
- Memo
- Pinball Machine
- Air Horn
- Bunk Bed
- DS
- Musicy
- Star
- Calendar
- Bad Songy
- Pansage
- Clow Card Fly
- Butter
- Rainbow 1
- Rainbow 2
- Nyan Cat
- Gumball
- Football
- Bracelety
- Vileplume
- TDC
- Skarlet
- Squarepants
- Cody
- Wonder Woman
- Wave
- Microwave
- Songy
- TNT
- Jack the Stickguy
- Spider Firey
- Magnet
- Cans of Goods
- Chocolate
- Toon Link
- Ghost
- Coiny and Firey (Win Token and Frozen Firey)
- Fishy
- Lava Lamp
- Nicole the Cowgirl
- Cookie
- Sandy
- Smoke Detector
- Universey
- Sphere
- Bouncy Ball
- Ball
- Evil Rocky
- Evil Chiclet
- Robot Rocky
- Rocky Clone
- Chalk
- Entire Inanimate Insanity Cast
- Acid Bubble
- Evil Bubble
- Annoying Orange
- Pear
- Apple
- Giant I
- Hammer
- Socky
Others
These have appeared when the Announcer traded each point for a teddy bear.
- Teddy Bear
- Yellow Teddy