- Main article: Evil Versions of Characters#Evil Bubble
Evil Bubble is a recommended character recommended by Rhinobuddroblox, 1dra7, and KaraidsLair.
- Main article: Black Hole
Vortex, aka Black Hole, was a threat to Firey, Spongy, and Bubble. It was recommended by maristanaweb.
- Main article: Sky
Sky makes another cameo, recommended by krazyjordan7. He/she appears when Speaker says the eliminated contestants will vote on who will be eliminated.
Acid Ice Cube
- Main article: Variations of Ice Cube#Acid Ice Cube
- Main article: Variations of Pin#Angel Pin
- Main article: Variations of Coiny#Blue Coiny
- Main article: Variations of Rocky#Blue Rocky
David's Best Friend
- Main article: Variations of David#David's Best Friend
- Main article: Variations of Teardrop#Electric Teardrop
- Main article: Evil Versions of Characters#Evil Spongy
- Main article: Variations of David#Exploding David
Female Speaker Box
- Main article: Variations of Announcer#Female Speaker Box
- Main article: Variations of Flower#Giant Flower
- Main article: Variations of Pin#Giant Pin
- Main article: Variations of David#Good David
Mini Dream Island
- Main article: Variations of Pin#Octo Pin
- Main article: Variations of Pencil#Orange Pencil
Pencil and Pen's BabyPencil & Pen's Baby appears as a graphite rod releasing purple ink. They may not be Pencil and Pen's child because they are a recommend character.
- Main article: Nickel
- Main article: Variations of Pin#Pinerific
- Main article: Variations of Pin#Plasma Pin
- Main article: Variations of Firey#Purple Firey
- Main article: Variations of Pin#Rainbow Pin
Screamers, Evil BFDI Cast, Entire BFDI Cast and BFDI Contestant
Screamers/Evil BFDI Cast/Entire BFDI Cast/BFDI Contestant is a mix of four recommended characters made into one. Despite their name, they only appear as the regular BFDI cast, which means that David was excluded.Screamers was recommended by alexlion0511. Evil BFDI Cast was recommended by Rhinobuddroblox. Entire BFDI Cast was recommended by Ben1178. BFDI Contestant was recommended by usacakeslol.
- Main article: Variations of Announcer#Speaker's Wife
- Main article: Variations of Firey#Super Firey
Weird Speaker Box
- Main article: Variations of Announcer#Weird Speaker Box
- Main article: Variations of Eraser#White Eraser
- Main article: Variations of Pin#Winged Pin
BlimpyBlimpy is a gray, limbless air blimp with the following text on it in white:
- WATCH BFDI
- OR WE'LL
- FIND YOU
Bomb, Nuke and Explosiony
- Main article: Bomby
Bomb, Nuke and Explosiony were three separate recommended characters that shared Bomby's asset.
- Main article: Bottle
Bottle CapBottle Cap is a white, limbless plastic bottle cap.
- Main article: Bracelety
- Main article: Cake
Doggie was recommended by BakuraSpoon. It is a brown dog with a purple nose. Doggie is probably based off of a chocolate Labrador retriever, a breed of dog.
Dollar Bill was recommended by mamaweegee64 and thewizardingwands. It is a dollar bill. It looks exactly identical to Red Dollar Bill but green.
Emo FeatherEmo Feather is a recommended character that appeared in Gardening Hero as one of the gaspers. He/she is a silver worn feather. Other then that, nothing else is known about him/her.
Fat TV was recommended by SBproductions12. It looks exactly like TV except their asset is stretched horizontally, hence its name. It
Flash DriveFlash drive is a red USB flash drive with "50TB" written on it, which means fifty terabytes.
- Main article: Gaty
Pee-eyPee-ey is recommended by tyboy618. They are a puddle of pee. They are also one of the two characters to be a bodily fluid, the other being Poop.
- Main article: Poop
PopsiclePopsicle is a green armless popsicle.
Red Dollar Bill
Red Dollar Bill was recommended by Pacothediscoking. It looks exactly identical to Dollar Bill, but red, as suggested by its name
- Main article: Ring
Saturn appeared in Gardening Hero among the second group of recommended gaspers.
SlippySlippy is a slipper with purple polka-dots.
SnakeySnakey is lime with vermillion polka-dots. It is a snake, a type of reptile in real life. It was recommended by theviperman77, which had recommended a variation of Snakey before, and lennonluiz0907.
Toxic Waste Can
TrousersTrousers is a pair of navy blue trousers. He is a character in BFSP which is a BFDI camp.
Army Bunny is a white, long eared rabbit with a forest green baseball cap with the word "ARMY" written across it.
ChuChu is shown as one of the gaspers, despite its mouth not opening. It is a red chuchu from the Legend of Zelda, a video game series developed by Japanese video game company Nintendo. It was recommended by YARDI0VICH.
FebreezeFebreeze is a spray can.
Fluffy Purple Cupcake
Fluffy Purple Cupcake was recommended by TheZappingManectric. It has a design that looks identical to Yoyle Ice Cream Cupcakes's except with different colors. It is a purple cupcake with a white wrapper and sprinkles.
Indonesia MapIndonesia Map is Indonesia, an island nation in Southeast Asia.
Justin BieberJustin Bieber is a badly drawn variation of David, based on the singer who started his career from his YouTube channel. He has blonde hair, wearing a purple New York Yankees hat.
Maltese IslandsMaltese Islands is Malta, an island nation in the continent of Europe.
- Main article: Variations of David#Meloetta
MinnesotaMinnesota is Minnesota, a state from USA.
Nintendo 64 Controller
Porygon is based on Porygon, a character in the game series Pokémon. In fact, its design in the episode was taken from, if not identical to, its original counterpart. It was recommended by luigifan00001.
Sonic the Hedgehog
SpamSpam is a can of Spam meat with the line "Go to my channel!" written on top of it. It was recommended by BFDIFAN9001.
SpookySpooky is a poorly drawn black cat who appeared as one of the gaspers in Gardening Hero. He is also a character in Englishcreamcake's (the recommender) show called Fight For Feline Funds, in which he won the show.
Super Creepy Face
- Main article: Variations of David#Vincent Lecavalier
Wii RemoteWii Remote was one of the gaspers.
YouTubers paviaedwin and bobbo44445 recommended "Blue Match", a recommended character who was really Match's hair dyed blue.