Some days I survive; other days I don't. It's no big deal either way.
— Pie, Fortunate Ben

Pie is a female object contestant on Battle for BFDI. She was one of the 30 recommended characters in The Reveal and Reveal Novum. Along with Remote and Grassy, Pie only received 7 votes, which in turn placed them at 16th and she was sent into the Locker of Losers.

There is another similar recommended character called Pie Man (recommended by Flykydfly) in "Half a Loaf Is Better Than None".

In the audition tape, as well as in "Bowling, Now With Explosions!", Pie is seen to be an explosive blueberry pie, and she was used as a cake at Cake at Stake. As shown in "Getting Teardrop to Talk", all blueberries in BFDI are explosive.

In "Yeah, Who? I Wanna Know", Pie only received 104 votes and placed 42nd, which wasn't enough to join BFDIA and she was sent to the LOL.

Pie's IDFB redesign features a light gray tin, and less of her pie crust is showing, which lost its detail. In addition, her face now switched to the pie crust, which was previously on the plate. She got 110 votes, tying with 8-Ball and Marker. [1]




  • Pie has shading.
  • Pie's tin is dark gray.
  • Pie has 3 visible holes.


  • Pie's crust and tin are lighter.
  • Pie's face is on her crust instead of her tin.
  • Pie now has only two visible holes.
  • Pie's crust loses its detail.


Pie seems to have a mellow and relaxed personality, despite the fact that she explodes frequently for seemingly no reason. She could also be described as apathetic, showing no strong opinion towards losing a tic-tac-toe game, or having Black Hole and Liy on her team. She shows mild disappointment when finding out that Black Hole can't push anything. Despite this, she is excited at Loser's appearance, as her head (quite literally) exploded in Getting Teardrop to Talk when she saw him.


Battle for BFDI

In Getting Teardrop to Talk, Pie is first seen playing tic-tac-toe with Cake, though she lost. Pie didn't mind, however. When Loser appears, Pie is seen in the crowd, where she exploded from excitement. Later, when Flower calls upon Black Hole, Pie is seen being sucked towards him along with the Pie Recovery Center. After Four appears, Pie suggests that Liy should try squishing him to find out what he is. When the teams start forming, Snowball asks if Pie has killed anyone, to which she responds that she hasn't. While this turns away Snowball, it intrigues Liy and Black Hole, who join Pie in order to learn from her. Throughout the rest of the episode, Pie is either absent or simply lounging in the background.

In Lick Your Way to Freedom, Pie is seen inspecting one of the jawbreakers Black Hole sliced, though she finds no one inside.

In Why Would You Do This on a Swingset, Pie appears in the cold open, where she is stabbed by one of Gelatin's thrown forks, causing her to explode. Before the challenge starts, Pie is quickly revived by Four. During the challenge, Pie is apparently disappointed that Black Hole can't push anything.

She attempts grabbing the Liar Ball in The Liar Ball You Don't Want, but is soon zapped by Lightning, which causes her to fly into the distance.

In This Episode Is About Basketball, Pie suggests an easy answer to the challenge, so Pen proceeds to throw many balls into Black Hole, but it has no effect. The whole team, except for Tree, Bottle, and Black Hole do the challenge normally and get 7th place.

In "Enter the Exit", she bends X's leg to make a Four. She later scolds Remote for sending A Better Name Than That a bomb, stating that it went against the team's goal of preventing death.



In Bowling, Now with Explosions!, when the Announcer said that they'd have a blueberry Pie this time, Bubble responds with a "yum!" When she received a slice, she responded with "yeah!"


Pie is apparently friends with Cake. She is seen playing tic-tac-toe together with Cake in Getting Teardrop to Talk.


  1. Half a Loaf Is Better Than None: Walks into a vat of hydrochloric acid.
  2. Bowling, Now with Explosions!: Is cut into slices by the Announcer.
  3. The Reveal: Explodes herself.
  4. Reveal Novum: Is crushed by the sun along with the other recommended characters in the LOL.
  5. Getting Teardrop to Talk: Explodes from excitement over seeing Loser.
  6. Why Would You Do This on a Swingset: Explodes when a fork is thrown at her by Gelatin.



Pie TeamIcon
Click here to view the gallery.


BFDI contestants


BFDIA contestants

Recommended characters
8-BallBalloonyBarf BagBasketballBellBlack HoleBottleBraceletyCakeClockCloudyEggyFannyFirey Jr.GatyGrassyLightningLollipopMarkerNailyNonexistyPiePillowRemoteRobot FlowerRobotySawTacoTreeTV

Death P.A.C.T.
Death P.A.C

Current: Black HoleBottlePenPiePillowRemoteTree

Eliminated: Liy