This is a list of variations of the recommended character Cake.
Two Birthday Cakes appeared in Hurtful!. They just stood in place while Leafy and Bubble were competing. They are strawberry cakes supposedly for someone’s birthday. One is recommended by imindabath, and the other by n64boys.
Carrot Cake appeared in Return of the Hang Glider. It watched the final elimination with other cakes. It is self-explanatory, the species is a carrot cake. It looks like a lighter version of Orange Cake that has carrots. It was recommended by lawman12345.
Cheese Cake appeared in Don't Pierce My Flesh. It watched the 4 contestants compete in The Volcano before dying from lava. It is simply a cheese cake. It is recommended by legoimovie, or at least we think, because the “no sign“ from No Cake Sign is blocking the paper.
Fluff Purple Cupcake appeared in Gardening Hero. It is one of the gaspers of when a contestant was going to rejoin Battle For Dream Island. It is a purple frosted cupcake with sprinkle. It is recommended by TheZappingManectric.
Giant Purple Cake
Giant Purple Cake appeared in Hurtful!. It stayed in place while Bubble and Leafy were competing. It is a strawberry cake dyed purple, since you can still see the traditional colors of cakes in BFDI, red, pink, and white a little. It is recommended by energeticmilo.
Two Cakes appeared in Bowling, Now with Explosions!. They are some of the former viewers of the elimination before catching on fire. They appear to be strawberry cakes. They were recommended by jmarston123 and xXangelwings1234Xx.
No Cake Sign appeared in Don't Pierce My Flesh. It was watching thefinal4 compete in The Volcano while staying in place. It is a strawberry cake with an eye-patch with the no symbol over it. It is recommended by monkeymonful.
Orange Cake appeared in Return of the Hang Glider. It watched the final elimination time. It can be orange (fruit) flavored, or dyed orange (color). It kinda looks like Carrot Cake, just a bit darker and without carrots. It is recommended by SBProductions12, a popular fan in BFDI.
Rainbow Cake appeared in Return of the Hang Glider. It is one of the cakes watching the finale. It is a rainbow-dyed cake. It is recommended by luigifan00001.
Red Velvet Chess Cake
Red Velvet Chess Cake appeared in Return of the Hang Glider. It was watching the final Cake at Stake inside BFDI. It is a red velvet cake. It is recommended by chimcharman123.
Robot Cake is a recommended character in BFB 9. They were recommended by WakelessLon. They appear to be a robotic version of Cake. They're made up of panels and legs similar to Robot Flower and Robot Tree. They are armless.
Yoyle Ice Cream Cupcakes (debatable)
Yoyle Ice Cream Cupcakes appeared in Return of the Hang Glider. It was watching the final Cake at Stake. It is just one cupcake despite the name. This is made of Yoyle ice cream, possibly a new Yoyle dish. It is recommended by DaKillahBunnyz.
Yoylecake appeared in Don't Pierce My Flesh, Hurtful!, and The Liar Ball You Don't Want. They are a Yoylecake (being a slice in their first appearance and second appearance and a whole cake in their third appearance). It was recommended by jumphi100 in BFDI 22, KaraidsLair in BFDI 23, and Jeremy E. in BFB 7. They stood in place as everyone gasped from Loser's elimination.