It is based off the real life American Flag with red and white stripes and a blue square on the top left corner, but the stars are replaced by a white smiley face. In Episode 13, he is partially part of a chain reaction of a ball hitting Blocky, which leads to Firey lighting Blocky and Ice Cube on fire. At that point, he has a frowny face instead.
Ball is a blue ball with a slightly deformed circle as a body, and has a circular gradient making their color lighter near the upper right of their body. They are also armless. In the episode, Ball is seen when Eraser and Pen are talking, and Ball is seen with a frowning expression. This exact asset, or maybe even character, is used as another character called Gumball, who has a different recommender.
- Main article: Balloony
Batteries are two identical recommended characters that were recommended in Episode 13 by the creator of BFDI, jacknjellify. They are both found inside Remote. In Don't Lose Your Marbles, Batteries came out of Remote and spilled acid that melted Pencil and Snowball (coincidentally having the same voter mentioned in a context related to them). In The Reveal, Remote took Batteries out of himself in his audition, making him faint. They resemble Duracell AA batteries.
- Main article: Bottle
- Main article: Cloudy
- Main article: Crayon
Dice is a recommended character who was recommended by simondomino in Episode 13. It is an armless die with his 1, 2, and 4-sides showing. In Episode 13, it, while frowning, is watching Blocky look for a ball. This fits with his asset being a recolor of Blocky's.
- Main article: Football
Peanut is a recommended character who was recommended by yummysimon4 in Episode 13. In that episode, Peanut was seen with Nutcracker when Eraser turned in a ball. At that point, Peanut is frowning, probably because it was scared of Nutcracker.
Peanut Butter is a recommended character who was recommended by simondomino in Episode 13. Peanut Butter is a limbless brown blob of peanut butter. In Episode 13, Peanut Butter was seen next to Phone when Eraser is looking for a ball. Firey also mentioned Peanut Butter before in episode 12, when he tasted something like peanut better.
Peanut might be friends with Peanut Butter because the latter is made out of peanuts.
Phone is a recommended character who was recommended by simondomino in Episode 13. Phone is a gray, armless cordless phone without any buttons. In Episode 13, Phone was seen standing (while frowning) next to Peanut Butter when Eraser is looking for a ball.
- Main article: Remote
Rose is a recommended character who was recommended by firemoss1 in Episode 13. It is always smiling, and looks happy. It was seen standing behind Match, and then hiding in a bush behind Announcer. It is so far the only recommended character who was not up for joining BFDI with more than 1 pose. It also has green-colored limbs instead of the usual black limbs.
He/She also appeared in Episode 18, where Scissors was on Laddy. Tennis Ball hit Laddy, making him/her flying and cutting Ropey and causing Hammer to fall.
TNT, with a slight-confused face, was standing infront of Eraser when he was asking what the contest was.
TNT might be friends with Bomby, as both of them are explosives.
- Main article: Tree
Wandy is a generic magic wand (a black rod capped with white at the top) without arms. In Episode 13, Wandy is seen smiling when Leafy turns in a red ball.
- Dice's name should be "Die", as the singular form of dice is "die". This is why the character's name was shown with "[sic]" next to it.
- Despite it being night time, Knife's shining is still shown. Obviously, despite the fact that the video is not pitch black, there is absolutely no way there could possibly be any sort of light source at night.