Contestants in BFDI were made in different, as Cary called, "generations", in the first challenge of BAGUETTE. There are 5 generations.
- Generation 1, First BFDI drawing ever, 5th grade Firey Comics #1: Firey, Woody, Teardrop, Spongy, Match.
- Generation 2, Firey Expansion: Pencil, Eraser, Bubble.
- Generation 3, Firey Comics, #2 #3: Coiny, Tennis Ball, Flower, Ice Cube.
- Generation 4, Total Firey Island: Blocky, Snowball, Rocky, Golf Ball.
- Generation 5, Total Firey Points / Battle for Dream Island: Needle, Pen, Leafy, Pin, David.
Generation 1 characters
Firey: The first character.
Generation 2 characters
Generation 3 characters
Generation 4 characters
Generation 5 characters
David, the last character.