This is the list of the 20 first ever voters for each characters in BFDI.
- Flower: jaysillyboy
- Spongy: jaysillyboy
- Blocky: VivaPinata0407
- Woody: losmmorpg
- Pin: muumuucui
- Needle: Supercrash1221
- Teardrop: yumyumhappyfishtails
- Golf Ball: Unknown. First known Golf Ball voter: laurasusanoosterhof
- Coiny: TotalPokeDramaFan
- Snowball: numbuh53
- Match: asmanwoks
- Eraser: hoppieeatpie
- Pen: Unknown. First known Pen voter: kirbygirlz
- Tennis Ball: Unknown. First known Tennis Ball voter: kirbygirlz
- Pencil: englishcreamcakes
- Ice Cube: losmmorpg (oddball)
- Rocky: cherryhill420
- Bubble: ArtOfLiving123
- Leafy: spakwee
- Firey: losmmorpg
Of all these voters, losmmorpg has been the first voter the most times, at three first votes: Woody, Ice Cube, and Firey. He only got mentioned for Ice Cube though.
- Pencil is the last one to have a first voter, being Englishcreamcakes in The Reveal.