These characters were destroyed by Pencil because she was "tired of [them] too". (With the exception of Emergency Button who was used to disintegrate them)
- Main article: Acid Bubble
Block-of-Cheesy is a recommended character who appeared in Rescission. Block-of-Cheesy was one of the characters that was disintegrated by Pencil with the Emergency Button. It was recommended by yoshboy19.
- Main article: Bracelety
- Main article: Variations of Pencil#Broken Pencil
Bunk Bed is one of the recommended characters that Pencil disintegrated with the Emergency Button in Rescission. It was recommended by DeeandEd. It is a poorly-drawn bunk bed, with a pink sheet on the top bed, and a blue sheet on the bottom one. Its limbs and face is occupied by the bottom bed.
Butter is a recommended character that appeared in Rescission. Butter is a badly-drawn yellow butter placed on a white plate. Butter was one of the characters to be disintegrated by Pencil with Emergency Button. It was recommended by oneamedmario.
Cans of Goods
Clow Card Fly
- Main article: Variations of David#Clow Card Fly
Coiny and Firey
Companion Cube is a recommended character recommended by Nelsa13luv. He/She appeared in Reveal Novum. He/She is also seen in BFDIA 5b in levels 8, 9 and 10. Its last appearance is in level 10, where it was sadly fell off but no choice to pass the level.
- Main article: Crayon
Emergency Button is a recommended character (by yummysimon4) that appeared in Rescission. It was used by Firey to disintegrate Bubble at the start of the episode, then Pencil on Firey, and lastly Pencil on the other recommended characters in the episode. It was presumably eaten by Rocky. It was recommended by yummysimon4.
It is a red button with a sad face. Upon being pressed, its face expression will change to smiling, and it will glow yellow. When activated, Emergency Button has the power to fire lasers that will disintegrate other objects upon contact.
Entire Inanimate Insanity Cast
Entire Inanimate Insanity Cast is a recommended character from Episode 19 as one of the recommended characters that got disintergrated when Pencil pressed the Emergency Button at them. Like the name suggest, they are the full Season 1 cast of Inanimate Insanity contestants. Coincidentally, they were recommended by AnimationEpic, the creator of the show mentioned above.
- Main article: Evil Versions of Characters#Evil Bubble
- Main article: Evil Versions of Characters#Evil Rocky
- Main article: Football
Hotdog is a recommended character in Episode 19. They got disintegrated by Pencil with the Emergency Button. They are a sausage hotdog on a long sliced bun with mustard on it. They were recommended by huntgums1.
Jack the Stickguy
- Main article: Variations of David#Jack the Stickguy
- Main article: Lava Lamp
Nicole the Cowgirl
- Main article: Variations of David#Nicole the Cowgirl
- Main article: Variations of David#Pansage
Speaker CloneSpeaker Clone is one of the recommended characters who got disintegrated by Pencil's Emergency Button in Rescission. It is a duplicate clone of the Announcer. It was recommended by eguiletafamily. As for this, it looks exactly alike to the Announcer, if not the same.
- Main article: Variations of Firey#Spider Firey
- Main article: Variations of David#Squarepants
Star is a recommended character who appeared in Rescission. They are a yellow-colored star. They were recommended by TheLegobatman3609. In the episode, they were disintegrated by Pencil using the Emergency Button, along with Firey and the rest of the recommended characters.
- Main article: Variations of David#TDC
- Main article: Variations of David#Toon Link
- Main article: Variations of David#Vileplume
Wave is a recommended character that appeared in Rescission. Wave was one of the characters to be disintegrated by Pencil with Emergency Button. It is badly-drawn, dark blue wave portion. It was recommended by HaitsZack.
- Main article: Variations of David#Wonder Woman
- Main article: Variations of Leafy#Yellow Leafy
These have appeared when the Announcer traded each point for a teddy bear.
- Main article: Teddy Bear
- In BFDIA 5b, at level 10, Book have to activate a lever that makes the platforms under the Companion Cube disappear so she could complete the level, which killed the Companion Cube, similar to the actual game Portal, in which the game Companion Cube was in, where the Companion Cube must be incinerated so the character could complete the level.
- In the BFDI Recommended Characters video, Entire Inanimate Insanity Cast is accidentally listed to appear in Reveal Novum.