- For the second season, see BFDIA elimination table.
|Episode 1-7 Team||Episode 8 Team||Episode 9 Team||Episode 10 Team||Episode 11 Team||1||2||3||4||5||61||72||82||9||10||11||12M||13||14||15||16I||174||18||19P||204||21||22||23||242||256|
|1st||Firey||Squishy Cherries||Squashy Grapes||Another Name||IN||WIN||IN||IN||IN||IN||WIN||WIN3||WIN||MID||IN||HIGH||MID||MID||IN||MID||WIN||MID||HIGH||WIN||RISK||HIGH||WIN||HIGH||WINNER|
|4th||Flower||Squashy Grapes||IN||OUT||Returns in The Glistening||RISK||WIN||OUT||P.E.|
|5th||Spongy||Squishy Cherries||IN||WIN||OUT||Returns in Half a Loaf Is Better Than None||MID||MID||IN||IN||RISK||RISK||IN||WINR||OUT||P.E.|
|6th||Rocky||Squashy Grapes||Another Name||Squishy Cherries||IN||IN||WIN||WIN||WIN||WIN||MID||WIN||WIN||MID||RISK3||WIN||MID||RISK||MID||RISK||IN||IN||MID||WIN||IN||OUT||Permanently Eliminated|
|7th||Ice Cube||Squashy Grapes||IN||IN||WIN||WIN||WIN||WIN||IN||WIN||WIN||IN||IN||MID||WIN||IN||RISK||MID||IN||IN||MID||IN||OUT||Permanently Eliminated|
|8th||David||Debuts in Reveal Novum||MID||OUT||Permanently Eliminated|
|9th (unfairly)||Pencil||Squishy Cherries||IN||WIN||IN||IN||IN||IN||MID||IN||IN||WIN||WIN||WIN||MID||WIN||MID||WIN||IN||IN||WIN/OUT5||Permanently Eliminated|
|10th||Tennis Ball||Squashy Grapes||Another Name||IN||IN||WIN||WIN||WIN||WIN||MID||WIN||WIN||MID||MID||RISK3||RISK||IN||MID||MID||RISK||OUT||Permanently Eliminated|
|11th||Blocky||Squishy Cherries||Squashy Grapes||IN||WIN||IN||OUT||Returns in Insectophobe's Nightmare||IN||IN||MID||MID||MID||WIN||MID||OUT||Permanently Eliminated|
|12th||Pen||Squishy Cherries||IN||WIN||IN||IN||IN||RISK||WIN||IN||IN||WIN||WIN||WIN||WIN||MID||MID||OUT||Permanently Eliminated|
|13th||Eraser||Squishy Cherries||IN||WIN||IN||IN||IN||IN||WIN||IN||IN||WIN||WIN||WIN||MID||MID||OUT||Permanently Eliminated|
|14th||Match||Squishy Cherries||IN||WIN||IN||IN||IN||IN||MID||IN||IN||WIN||WIN||WIN||MID||OUT||Permanently Eliminated|
|15th||Snowball||Squashy Grapes||Squishy Cherries||IN||IN||WIN||WIN||WIN||WIN||MID||WIN||WIN||RISK3||WIN||WIN||OUT||Permanently Eliminated|
|16th||Coiny||Squashy Grapes||Another Name||IN||IN||WIN||WIN||WIN||WIN||RISK||WIN||WIN||MID||MID||OUT||Permanently Eliminated|
|17th||Golf Ball||Squashy Grapes||Another Name||IN||RISK||WIN||WIN||WIN||WIN||MID||WIN||WIN||MID||RISK/OUT||Permanently Eliminated|
|18th||Teardrop||Squashy Grapes||IN||IN||WIN||WIN||WIN||WIN||MID||WIN||WIN||RISK/OUT||Permanently Eliminated|
|19th||Needle||Squashy Grapes||IN||IN||WIN||WIN||WIN||WIN||OUT||Permanently Eliminated|
|20th||Pin||Squishy Cherries||WIN||WIN||IN||IN||RISK||OUT||Permanently Eliminated|
|Woody||Squishy Cherries||IN||WIN||RISK||RISK||OUT||Permanently Eliminated|
WINNER- This contestant had the most votes and won Dream Island.
RUNNER-UP- This contestant had the second most votes and therefore was the runner-up.
THIRD-This contestant had the least amount of votes to win Dream Island and attained Third Place.
WIN-This contestant won the individual challenge (Episode 1 Part 1/Post-Merge) and earned immunity (Episode 18 onwards) or was on the winning team (Episode 1 Part 2 onwards/Pre-Merge).
MID-This contestant neither won nor lost (3 Teams)/did not fell into the Danger Zone (Post-Merge).
WIN/IN-This contestant won the challenge but gave his/her immunity up to someone else.
Cake at Stake
HIGH- This contestant is the first person to had their named called at Cake at Stake.
IN- Elimination Challenge: This contestant had their named called at Cake at Stake but was safe / Non-Elimination Challenge: This contestant/team lost the challenge.
IN- This contestant did not win the challenge but still granted immunity.
RISK-This contestant was declared safe last.
OUT-This contestant received the most votes for elimination and therefore is eliminated.
OUT-This contestant received the most votes by other contestants and was eliminated.
WIN/OUT-This contestant won the challenge, but was put up for elimination and was eliminated.
RISK/OUT-This contestant received the second most votes for elimination and was eliminated, but the person with the most votes was declared safe.
Overall, the Cake at Stake-related keys have been placed according to the challenges to avoid overlapping.
L-Leafy gave her immunity to Spongy.
M-In this episode, the teams merged and contestants competed alone.
P-In this episode, points were removed from the game.
I-In this episode, only the contestant who won the challenge has immunity.
R-Although this contestant did not earn immunity by winning the challenge, he/she earned immunity by another winning contestant.
1-In this episode, the 2 teams are put into teams of three. The last team to complete the challenge will be up for elimination.
2-In this episode, there is no voting for elimination based on the challenge. (The first episode is not supposed to have eliminations)
3-This contestant swapped teams in the end (in Firey's case) of the challenge or during (for the three teams' case) Cake at Stake.
4-The contestants choose who to be eliminated next episode.
5-Due to the score board only holding two digit numbers, Pencil was up for elimination and was eliminated.
6-Instead of voting a contestant out in this episode, voters choose who will win Dream Island.