"This is shooting BFDI Second Season Voting off like, a cliff, with my Not Cannon !" — Match , "HELP US get to VIDCON 2019 " (altered)
The subject of this article or section is non-canon . The events described did not happen in the official BFDI universe.
"BFDI Second Season Voting " was a video uploaded on February 12, 2012, where viewers got to vote on who would join BFDI's second season, BFDIA . The 20 most voted contestants would join. Viewers were allowed to vote for any contestant up to 20 times, as long as the votes were all on one comment. 60 contestants were up for voting: the original BFDI cast, the thirty recommended characters that had a chance to join BFDI in "Reveal Novum ", and 10 other recommended characters.
Results [ ]
Italic text means the character joined BFDIA.
Place
Contestant
Votes
In
1st
Rocky
1,008
Yes
2nd
Nickel
892
Yes
3rd
Firey
724
Yes
4th
*Leafy
606
No
5th
Teardrop
585
Yes
6th
Bomby
582
Yes
7th
*Bubble
556
No
8th
Needle
489
Yes
9th
Spongy
456
Yes
10th
Dora
439
Yes
11th
Pin
405
Yes
12th
Ruby
381
Yes
13th
Tennis Ball
359
Yes
14th
Coiny
334
Yes
15th
Pencil
320
Yes
16th
Match
315
Yes
17th
Ice Cube
313
Yes
18th
*Flower
312
No
19th
Donut
307
Yes
20th
Fries
303
Yes
21st
†Book
296
Yes
22nd
†Yellow Face
292
Yes
23rd
†Puffball
291
Yes
24th
TV
287
No (Became host)
25th
Pen
285
No
26th
Black Hole
269
No
27th
*Nonexisty
266
No
28th
*Woody
266
No
29th
David
251
No
30th
Blocky
239
No
31st
‡Golf Ball
215
Yes
32nd
Eraser
185
No
33rd
Firey Jr.
179
No
34th
Taco
159
No
35th
8-Ball
154
No
36th
Fanny
153
No
37th
Snowball
143
No
38th
Cake
134
No
39th
Robot Flower
119
No
40th
Remote
115
No
41st
Marker
109
No
42nd
Pie
104
No
43rd
Balloony
102
No
44th
Naily
100
No
45th
Cloudy
97
No
46th
Lollipop
95
No
47th
Lightning
93
No
48th
Evil Leafy
90
No
49th
Bell
90
No
50th
Basketball
86
No
51st
Pillow
79
No
52nd
Barf Bag
78
No
53rd
Eggy
77
No
54th
Clock
59
No
55th
Gaty
54
No
56th
Grassy
53
No
57th
Roboty
50
No
58th
Tree
49
No
59th
Saw
36
No
60th
Bottle
29
No
61st
Bracelety
18
No
N/A
‡Gelatin
1
Yes
An * means that this contestant could not join BFDIA due to not being present.
A † means that this contestant joined BFDIA because other contestants were absent.
A ‡ means that this contestant joined BFDIA by being recommended by a winning viewer.
Total votes: 15,532
Total voters: 789
Trivia [ ]
Even though BFDIA had 22 contestants, the video says there would be only 20, like in Season 1. This is because this was announced before Gelatin and Golf Ball were picked by DegrassiFan and InternPony707 respectively.
This video marks the only instance where a single viewer could comment to vote multiple times.
Donut lacks arms in this video, but he has them in "Yeah, Who? I Wanna Know ".
Yellow Face was not up for voting, due to him being absent in the video. But a lot of people voted him, so Michael and Cary decided to let him join.
Puffball and Lollipop both have different designs from how they appear in BFDIA, with Puffball being hand-drawn and Lollipop having a more simple appearance.
Battle for Dream Island episodes and other videos
TFI: "Crying Contest " • "Balance Beam " • "Mile Run " • "Elimination Volleyball! " • "Rope Climb " • "Dodgeball " • "Spelling Bee " • "Breath Holding Contest " • "Dice! " • "Spinner " • "Bowling 1 " • "Bowling 2 " • "Stack 1 " • "Stack 2 " • "Hurdles 1 " • "Hurdles 2 " • "Hurdles 3 and 'WETHFPC' " • "Jumbo "
TFS: "Mountain Climb" (unreleased)
TFP: "Balance Beam" • "Dodge Ball" • "Mountain Climb" • "Balloon Toss" • "Teams" • "Boats" • "Bridge Crossing" • "Eating" • "Pyramid" • "Pole Vaulting" • "Test Taking" • "Obstacle Course" (all unreleased)
BF DI: "Take the Plunge (Take the Plunge: Part 1 " • "Take the Plunge: Part 2 )" • "Barriers and Pitfalls " • "Are You Smarter Than a Snowball? " • "Sweet Tooth " • "Bridge Crossing " • "Power of Three " • "Puzzling Mysteries " • "Cycle of Life " • "Insectophobe's Nightmare " • "Crybaby! " • "Lofty " • "A Leg Up in the Race " • "Don't Lose Your Marbles " • "Half a Loaf Is Better Than None " • "Vomitaco " • "Bowling, Now with Explosions! " • "The Reveal " • "Reveal Novum " • "Rescission " • "Gardening Hero " • "The Glistening " • "Don't Pierce My Flesh " • "Hurtful! " • "Insectophobe's Nightmare 2 " • "Return of the Hang Glider "
BF DI A: "Yeah, Who? I Wanna Know " • "Get Digging " • "Insectophobe's Nightmare 3 " • "Zeeky Boogy Doog " • BFDIA 5 ("Get in the Van " • "BFDIA 5b " • "No More Snow! " • "It's a Monster " • "The Long-lost Yoyle City ") • "Well Rested " • "Intruder Alert " • "Meaty " • "Catch These Hands " • "Taste the Sweetness "
IDFB: "Welcome Back "
BFB: "Getting Teardrop to Talk " • "Lick Your Way to Freedom " • "Why Would You Do This on a Swingset " • "Today's Very Special Episode " • "Fortunate Ben " • "Four Goes Too Far " • "The Liar Ball You Don't Want " • "Questions Answered " • "This Episode Is About Basketball " • "Enter the Exit " • "Get to the Top in 500 Steps " • "What Do You Think of Roleplay? " • "Return of the Rocket Ship " • "Don't Dig Straight Down " • "The Four is Lava " • "The Escape from Four " • "X Marks the Spot " • "Take the Tower " • "How Loe Can You Grow? " • "A Taste of Space " • "Let's Raid The Warehouse " • "Who Stole Donut's Diary? " • "Fashion For Your Face! " • "The Game Has Changed " • "The Tweested Temple " • "The Hidden Contestant " • "Uprooting Everything " • "B.F.B. = Back From Beginning " • "SOS (Save Our Show) " • "Chapter Complete "
BFDI:TPOT: "You Know Those Buttons Don't Do Anything, Right? " • "The Worst Day of Black Hole's Life " • "Getting Puffball To Think About Rollercoasters " • "Gardening Zero " • "Fishes and Dishes " • "The Great Goikian Bake-Off " • "The Seven Wonders of Goiky " • "Balancing P.A.C.T. " • "Outbreak At Stake " • "Oneirophobe's Nightmare "
Upcoming: IDFB 2 • BFDI:TPOT 11 • BFDIA 11
Shorts : "Thanks for 4 years! " • "BFDI Is Back " • "Paper Towel " • "Ballers " • "Thanks for 4 years of Thanks for 4 years! " • "HELP US get to VIDCON 2019 " • "Happy Birthday, Battle for BFDI! " • "BFDI's Road to Half a Billion Views " • "You're A Loser, But... " • "Thanks for 600,000 subscribers! " • "Thanks for 700,000 subscribers! " • "Aw, Seriously? " • "BFB Contestants React to Wiki Comments " • "Thanks for 800,000 subscribers! " • "PUMPKIN 2.0 - BFDI Halloween Shorts " • "If Among Us Was a BFDI Challenge " • "If X-MAS in Among Us was a BFDI Challenge " • "Thanks for 900,000 subscribers! " • "Thanks for 1,000,000 subscribers! " • "Thanks for 4 years of Thanks for 4 years of Thanks for 4 years! " • "Claustrophobe's Nightmare • "Twosday " • "Fish and Chips " • "Why is the BFDI Mouth everywhere? " • "Firey and Gelatin Steal a Van " • "Thanks for 1,500,000 Subscribers! " • "Thanks for 2,000,000 Subscribers! " • "Pie Vs Pi: The Pi Day Massacre "
BFDI Mini: BFDI Mini episodes • BFDI Mini Again episodes • BFDI Mini Deluxe episodes • BFDI Mini, Seriously! episodes • BFDI Mini Delicious episodes
Plush videos: "The Official Firey Plush is here! " • "Who's The Real Firey? (ft. Leafy Plush) " • "Hello Woody! (Now available to order) " • "The Loser Plush is here! " • "The Official Four and X Plush " • "Marker and Coiny plush have arrived! " • "when you bake a cake (ft. TWO PLUSH) "
Reanimated specials: "BFDI 1a+1b Reanimated! Fan-made MAP (Multi Animator Project) " • "BFDIA 1 Re-Animated By 95 People! - (Fan-Made) " • "IDFB 1 Re-Animated By 108 People! (Fan-Made) "
Cancelled/Unknown: Yoylecake Winning Celebration Cartoon • December 2016 Short • 50 million views video • Unknown announcement video
YTPMVs : "Intensive BFDI Unit " • "Rock My BFDI " • "BFDI-chapp " • "3000 Subbies " • "Eliminating BFDI " • Dear Viewers " • 6000 Subscribers " • "Thanks for 20,000 subscribers! (Last BFDI) " • "BFB 13 this Thursday. " • ""Revenge", except every syllable is from BFDI " • "UNREAL BFDI — Thanks for 1 Billion Views! " • "I HOPE ITS NOT ME - composed by @legotd61 "
Songs: "All I Want for X-mas — SONG by Four & X from BFB " • "Lo-Fi Beats to Yoyle To • "Message to Loser (Lyric Video) - SONG by Four from BFB " • "Jingle BELL Rock 🔔 Song with Four, Bell, Seven " • "Just Push Through It (Songify BFDI by Schmoyoho) " • "This Is BFB: Season Recap (Lyric Video) " • "Antony Kos - Hey Two! (Extended Cake at Stake song) Lyric Video " • "16 Years of Jacknjellify! 🎂 (Music Video) "
Promotional: "Vote Yoylecake " • "You can help BFDI win an Award! " • "VOTE for who the next BFDI PLUSH should be! " • "The Firey Plush is ON SALE + NEW BFDI HOODIE! " • "What if BFDI was in r/place? " • "BFDI *was* in r/place! " • "BFDI & Inanimate Insanity Meet Up! " • "TWO OF THEM!? - BFDI X Inanimate Insanity 2023 Event "
Meetup videos: "BFDI and II Finally Cross Over " • "*struggles to contain fans at 2019 meetup* " • "II + BFDI back together again! " • "The 22 Best Questions You Asked Us — BFDI + II Meetup " • "3,000 PEOPLE came to the BFDI x II Meetup in LA… "
Episode compilations: "Blocky Prank Compilation - Battle for Dream Island " • "Every FAKE AD in BFDI — Yellow Face Compilation " • "Best BFDI Crushes to Date! — Compilation "
TikTok compilations: "BFDI TikTok Compilation " • "Top BFDI/A TikToks Compilation " • "BFB TikTok Compilation " • "We asked TikTok to VOTE the best object - BFDI Mini " • "All our food does THIS... — BFDI's Best TikToks of 2020 " • "Firey Discovers Gravity (BFDI TikTok Compilation) " • "TikTok voted on our objects again: BFDI MINI DELUXE " • "10 "David"s, One Winner — BFDI MINI SERIOUSLY " • "A Food Battle for the Ages— BFDI MINI DELICIOUS "
Announcement videos: "??? " • "A super fresh minty clean announcement " • "Doing It Again! " • "BFDI Second Season Voting " • "12/12/12 " • "Choose Your Fate " • "Back 2 School Bad News " • "BFDI's Best Hiatus Ever " • "Bring BFDI Episode 1 Part 2 Back (also YouTube face reveal) " • "Let's keep BFDI casual "
Livestreams: "BFDI 1 "Take the Plunge" Tutorial Stream " • "IDFB comments game: FAKE OR REAL? " • "2918 meetup steam "
Other: Social media-exclusive animations • "The BeiBei Squisher " • "The Marble Race! " • "When Video Games Malfunction! " • "Doo Doo-Dee Doo " • "X Finds Out His Value " • "First BFDI Animation Ever " • "BFDI Fan Art Reviews " • "Salmon Fiveyears " • "BFDI APPISIOTE 225555555!!!!! " • "BFDI Mini-Season - "Marbles" " • "Happy Halloween " • "ABCDEFG " • "BFDIA 6 Deleted Scenes " • "The JingJing Squisher (10 year anniversary) " • "How to Fold your Foldy " • "The Lost Ice Cube Recordings " • "Battle for Dream Island: Official Character Guide Instagram promotion " • "BFDI Recommended Characters " • "Apply to join BFDI! Animators, Audio Editors, Background/Prop Artists and More " • "The Secret Behind BFB's Split " • "Recommend a Character - Become a Jacknjellify Member " • "We Discovered Our Forgotten "Firey" Comics " • "All BFDI soundboard videos! (compilation) " • "Best BFDI Season 1a moments (according to data from you viewers!) " • "The LOST NEWSPAPERS of Four and X "
Other pre-BFDI: Character Chart • Connections sheets • Earliest "First BFDI Animation" • Feb 20 2009 Character Bios • Fictional BFDI Election • Firey (comic series) • Firey Expansion • "FIREY to keep our customers happy " • Firey Yearbook • "Firey's Candy Bar Adventure " • "Michael's best comic " • School Planner • "The Number Playground Chronicle! "