|1st (Tied)||Bomby||No-Name||W.O.A.H Bunch||WIN||IN||WIN||WIN||MID|
|1st (Tied)||Coiny||W.O.A.H Bunch||HIGH (+)||WIN||RISK||WIN||MID|
|1st (Tied)||Firey||No-Name||WIN||IN||WIN||IN||PZN/RISK/IN (+)|
|1st (Tied)||Golf Ball||No-Name||WIN||IN||WIN||RISK||UFE|
|1st (Tied)||Ice Cube||No-Name||FreeSmart||WIN||IN||WIN||IN||WIN|
|1st (Tied)||Needle||No-Name||W.O.A.H Bunch||WIN||IN||HIGH||WIN||MID|
|1st (Tied)||Nickel||No-Name||W.O.A.H. Bunch||WIN||IN||WIN||IN||MID|
|1st (Tied)||Pin||W.O.A.H Bunch||RISK||WIN||IN||WIN||MID|
|1st (Tied)||Spongy||No-Name||W.O.A.H. Bunch||WIN||IN||WIN||IN||MID|
|1st (Tied)||Tennis Ball||No-Name||WIN||HIGH||WIN||IN||UFE|
|1st (Tied)||Yellow Face||No-Name||W.O.A.H Bunch||WIN||IN||WIN||WIN||MID|
|18th||Puffball||No-Name||WIN||IN (+)||WIN||IN (+)||OUT|
|19th (not officially in the game)||Bubble||No-Name/DEAD||FreeSmart||Revived in Insectophobe's Nightmare 3||WIN||MID||WIN/DISQUALIFIED|
|20th (Bubble not officially in the game)||Match||No-Name||FreeSmart||WIN||IN||WIN||OUT|
|21st (Bubble not officially in the game)||Teardrop||No-Name||W.O.A.H Bunch||WIN||WIN||PZ/OUT (+)|
|22nd (Bubble not officially in the game)||Dora||No-Name||WIN||OUT|
|23rd (Bubble not officially in the game)||Donut||W.O.A.H Bunch||OUT|
WIN - Elimination Challenge: This contestant was the winner, or was a member of the winning team in the previous challenge, and was safe.
IN (+) - Elimination Challenge: This contestant received the most likes for the reward.
IN - Elimination Challenge: This contestant had their named called at Cake at Stake and was safe but did not receive the reward.
RISK - This contestant was declared safe last.
OUT - This contestant received the most dislikes for elimination and therefore is eliminated.
OUT (+) - This contestant received a prize, but had the most dislikes. As their prize was not immunity, or any other means of avoiding elimination, they were eliminated.
HIGH - This contestant was declared safe first.
HIGH (+) - This contestant received a prize and was declared safe first.
MID - This contestant was in second place, or was on the team that placed second in the previous challenge, and was safe.
UFE/OUT - This contestant got the most dislikes and will be eliminated once the next episode is released.
UFE - This contestant is at stake (up for elimination).
PZN- This person will get the prize once the next episode is released.
- Teardrop won a prize in her elimination episode but also received the most elimination votes. Because she opted to receive a Hand-powered Recovery Center, instead of Immunity to the Final 15, she was eliminated.
- According to her alliance, Bubble was supposed to be in Team No-Name in episode 4, which was the losing team. However, due to not being considered an official contestant, Bubble was not up for elimination.
- Match wasn't officially in FreeSmart since she was eliminated before the team even existed. However, thanks to Pencil's "elimination prevention plan", she was considered a member before being flung to the TLC inside the LOL seven months later.