- Main article: Waffle
- Main article: Variations of Pencil#Carpenter's Pencil
Christmas Tree is a recommended character in BFDIA 5a. Christmas Tree is also one of the multiple Christmas-themed recommended characters for the episode. This character was recommended by ghostgirl7000, and placed 3rd in the Top 25 for that episode.
Christmas Tree appears to be a pine tree, with a yellow star on the top, a signature decor for trees in Christmas.
Cheeseburger is a character recommended by CobaltGameMixer676. It appeared in Get in the Van, as the 5th highest voted character in the top 25 recommended characters. Despite its name, it has no visible cheese, only meat and buns.
Onion Ring is a recommended character who appeared in Get in the Van. It placed 10th out of the Top 25 recommended characters. Onion Ring is a ring cut from an onion, a wordplay on the snack "Onion Ring". It was recommended by CobaltGameMixer676.
Soapy is a recommended character recommended by luvpuppy201. He/She appeared in Get in the Van, placing 12th out of the Top 25 recommended characters in that episode. He/She is a literal, armless solid soap. He/She is light tan-colored with a mischievous big smile.
- Main article: Variations of Firey#Christmas Firey
3DS is a recommended character who placed 16th out of the top 25 recommended characters in Get in the Van. It is a pearl pink Nintendo 3DS. The game onscreen appears to be GTTTATINT (Get To The Top Although There Is No Top). It was recommended by wifishark.
Star Fruit is one of 25 recommended characters to appear in BFDIA 5a. It placed 20th out of the 25 recommended characters. It was recommended by wifishark, along with some other recommended characters. It is a green and yellow stripe-colored oval star fruit.
Durian is one of the top 25 recommended characters in BFDIA 5a. It placed 24th in the Top 25 for Get in the Van, and was one of several recommended characters by wifishark. It is a dark green-colored durian, a type of fruit.
Eggplant is one of the few characters recommended by wifishark. Eggplant appeared in BFDIA 5a. It placed 25th out of the Top 25 Recommended Characters, barely getting the spot. It is a purple-colored eggplant, with green leaves on top.